Uncertainty in model-based decision-making : lessons for cumulative impact assessments
Author(s) |
Rienstra, J.J.
|
Mestdagh, S.M.F.
Publication type | Reference work
The Greater North Sea Basin is facing increasing pressure from expanding offshore activities, particularly renewable energy development, while the marine ecosystem is already in poor condition. Cumulative Impact Assessments (CIA) are essential tools within Maritime Spatial Planning (MSP) to support ecosystem-based management by assessing the combined effects of human activities. However, CIA outcomes are inherently uncertain due to limited data, complex ecological processes, and modelling assumptions.
This report focuses on uncertainty associated with the development, application, and interpretation of CIA models, rather than on all sources of uncertainty relevant to MSP and decision-making. It explains how such uncertainty arises, how it can be systematically assessed, and how it can be addressed in decision-making. Uncertainty is broader than data gaps alone; it is present in model boundaries, conceptual and technical model design, input data, implementation, and aggregated outputs.
The report presents the uncertainty matrix as a practical framework to classify uncertainty along three dimensions: where it occurs (location), how large it is (level), and what type it is (nature). Using this framework improves transparency and communication, particularly between modellers and policymakers.
A key distinction is made between modellers’ uncertainty, which concerns the analytical robustness of results, and policymakers’ uncertainty, which includes political priorities, governance arrangements, and strategic considerations. Recognising this difference is crucial to ensure CIA results are interpreted and used appropriately.
The report stresses that uncertainty should not necessarily delay action. Different levels of uncertainty require different approaches, ranging from sensitivity analyses to scenario planning and adaptive strategies. Assessing uncertainty early in the policy and planning process helps avoid surprises and supports robust decision-making.
Overall, the report concludes that uncertainty is unavoidable but manageable. Explicitly identifying, classifying, and communicating uncertainty strengthens the value of CIA and supports informed, timely MSP decisions in a dynamic marine environment.